Gold Community Okay -- Your Turn
    > Return to the Temple of Elemental Evil
        > Cold Effects
New Topic    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
Tribal28
Here for a while
(12/17/02 9:50:08 am)
Reply
Cold Effects
Ok I have a PC who is being "clever." When a fire elemental attacked the group (This happened in my lead up to tRtToEE) he was hit and had to make a save to avoid catching on fire. He shouldn't have to because he isn't wearing any clothes under his chain shirt. I made him anyway because he has hair that can catch, a backpack and a few other items that burn easily (and flesh can burn too, YUCK). Now as uncomfortable as it sounds I have seen many fantasy art images where there is no clothing being worn under chainmail. I've even seen a few people wearing chainmail-like shirts and such (Not quite authentic but still heavy and all) with out shirts underneath. (Yes I used to hang out in mosh-pits and the like) So I don't have a big issue with that image.
So say I give him a +1 bonus to his save for catching on fire.
What sort of rules should I give him for the cold areas or for cold type damage? exactly even and give him a -1 on saves? maybe make him take a little extra damage from the cold area near the obolisk? Anything I might be forgetting in general?
(like could he be more easily sunburned?)
Thanks for any input

Tribal

Trithereon
Here to stay
(12/17/02 10:17:09 am)
Reply
Catching Fire
There are times when gameplay and rules clash. A completely bald and naked monk fights a fire elemental. What's to catch fire?

I've always imagined that monsters like fire elementals may leave behind patches of "elemental residue" on a successful slam attack burning the victim on a failed saving throw. A successful save means that the victim managed to shake, wipe or pat it out the elemental residue.

It's a stretch and not supported by any rules regarding elemental attacks but I'd rather not have to come up with a set of circumstantial bonuses and penalties based upon how flamable, or inflamable, the character/monster is.

Thrommel
Can't leave now (mod)
(12/17/02 10:18:27 am)
Reply
Re: Cold Effects
{Anything I might be forgetting in general?}

I think you might be forgetting the -2 circumstance penalty to all attacks, damage, and skill checks from the horrible blisters and chafing the PC has.

Fantasy art is exactly that: fantasy. Doing anything strenuous with bare skin in chainmail is going to rub more than a few layers of skin off.

So if your player wants to take the game to the level of realism where what your PC is wearing has an effect on saves, I would simply tell him that's a level of detail that isn't supported by the system.

Or, as you point out, inform him you'll house rule fire saves in his favor, but cold and lighting damage are penalized, etc.

-Thrommel, who wears leather under his chainmail, and silk under his leather. Under that... well, that's none of your business unless your name is Jolene.

chartam
Here to stay
(12/17/02 10:22:45 am)
Reply
Re: Cold Effects
Besides, without any sort of padding under the mail, he'll have embedded rings in his flesh after any successful hit against his body...I've seen photos of what that looks like. It's the reason that the SCA frowns upon (I can't remember if they forbid it or not) the use of chainmail in their mock combats.

Chartam Plicatus, Paper Prestidigitator
- [Minibase] - [RttToEE Minis List] - [Campaign Website] -

ZansForCans 
Here for a while
(12/17/02 11:39:05 am)
Reply
Re: Cold Effects
Quote:
He shouldn't have to because he isn't wearing any clothes under his chain shirt.


Aside from the realism arguments...

On the easy side just tell him that he's going to take 1/2 the burning damage for 1d4 rounds (like burning) with no save for it to stop due to the searing metal in direct contact with his skin (unless he'd like to take it off). I'd also up the DC for the super-cold locations in the adventure that already mention it being harder for those wearing metal armor.

Another idea, although it's more work for you, is to read up on chill and heat metal spells. Maybe just being in melee with a fire elemental isn't as bad as the spell, but you could emulate the gradual heating if he's in melee with it for a long time.



Group Editing & Authoring Support
flexible campaign management for the web
info :: demo

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Email This To a Friend Email This To a Friend
Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
Unsubscribe Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- Okay -- Your Turn - Return to the Temple of Elemental Evil - Home -



Powered By ezboard® Ver. 7.229
Copyright ©1999-2003 ezboard, Inc.